Ben & Jerry’s Mint Cookies & Cream Ice Cream is my all-time favorite ice cream. The frozen white cream of the cookie mixed with mint ice cream is just so heavenly that I had to find a way to replicate it, albeit pareve, so that it could be enjoyed after a very meaty Shabbos meal. As I was playing around with this recipe I thought of Ben & Jerry who add lots of candy and cookies to their ice cream flavors, I decided to add some chocolate mint candy to it along with the cookies. Ice cream is to me what chocolate is to the rest of the world, making this combination absolutely irresistible.
16 ounces non-dairy topping (frozen parve whip cream in liquid form)
1 cup sugar (I used 1/2 cup sugar with 1/2 cup BaktoFlavors Golden Vanilla Sugar that has real vanilla beans in it)
1 cup soy or coconut milk
3/4 teaspoon of peppermint extract
1 cup crushed chocolate sandwich cookies with vanilla cream inside (parve)
1 cup mini chocolate mint lentils
optional: green food coloring. (I am not a fan of using food coloring so I don’t use this but if you need your mint ice cream to be green, that’s how you do it. )
Whip the non-dairy topping until creamy (not yet whipped) with an electric mixer
Add the sugar and soy milk and keep mixing until creamy
Fold in the crushed cookies and mint lentils
Freeze overnight in airtight container & enjoy!